
The Binding of Isaac developer Nicalis has removed undisclosed AI-generated music from the Repentance+ update following a wave of negative Steam reviews and a public statement from the game's creator, Edmund McMillen.
McMillen and Nicalis had spent months hyping the November 19, 2026 release of the latest update to their classic action roguelike, but the launch quickly turned sour. Only 8% of recent Steam reviews for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ are positive, with many players calling out the AI-generated content that had never been officially mentioned.
"Thanks, Nicalis, for breaking everything and adding AI slop to an already-existing game!" one popular review read.
Another said, "I'm starting to think that adding AI to a game should be valid grounds for refunds to people who have already paid for and played a game. Shameful they would do this to an Indie gem. Shameful."
The AI-generated content in question appears to be music tied exclusively to a Grand Theft Auto-themed run, likely meant to coincide with the recent release of GTA 6. What might have been a playful jab at another gaming giant instead spiraled into a full-blown controversy for Nicalis after Reddit user ShweetsStuff flagged the questionable tracks just one day after launch.
As AI technology advances, distinguishing human-made art from machine-generated content has become increasingly difficult, but ShweetsStuff provided evidence to support their claims. They pointed to several tracks whose metadata referenced the AI music software Suno, including links to their Suno pages.
AI-generated content passed off as art has already been controversial in recent years. Adding fuel to the fire for Repentance+ was the fact that the music was included in the new update without any update to its Steam description. Valve requires developers to disclose how they may have used AI during game development, making the music's inclusion both puzzling and concerning for those who felt Nicalis had pulled the wool over their eyes.
Negative reviews flooded in after ShweetsStuff's discovery, prompting McMillen to issue a statement. He said he "had no idea" how AI-generated music ended up in the launch build of the Repentance+ update.
"Woke up to a s**t show," he said. "Obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned."
Just hours later, Nicalis released a new patch confirming the "removal of generated music files." The update is now live on PC, and the studio added that it has already been submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony. A release date for those platforms has not been announced.
No explanation was given for how or why the AI-generated music was included. Instead, the team simply said it was "working on the game and will continue to address new and old bugs." McMillen also encouraged fans to report issues and bugs to the developers.
Meanwhile, recent Steam reviews for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ remain firmly in the "Overwhelmingly Negative" category. The major update also coincided with the launch of Repentance+ on new platforms, including Nintendo Switch 2, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X/S. For more, you can read IGN's 9/10 review of The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth and our 9/10 review of Afterbirth+.

UAE
Argentina
Austria
Australia
Belgium
Bulgaria
Brasil
Canada
Switzerland
Chile
Czech Republic
Germany
Denmark
Spain
Finland
France
United Kingdom
Greece
Hong Kong
Hungary
Indonesia
Ireland
Israel
India
Iceland
Italy
Japan
South Korea
Mexico
Malaysia
Netherlands
Norway
New Zealand
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Sweden
Singapore
Slovakia
Thailand
Taiwan
Ukraine RU
United States
South Africa


